The High Speed Pendulam

I read this morning, it’s completely nuts. China and America are indeed diametrically opposed.

China is on it’s way to building 30,000 miles of high speed rail. All paid for by borrowing, much of the rail is likely to be unnecessary. America has built 1% of that at best, our slogan is “What’s High Speed Rail?”

Yes, of course there is a much more sensible balance to find if the projects are funded from the public purse, aka mostly taxes. The other facet of this is the control and permission to build. Here in America, as in much of the developed world, permission to even do this would take years. This is where I have some empathy with the “government regulations crowd”. It’s very unlikely though they’ll do anything that benefits or eases infrastructure. We’ll see.

While the USA will have DOGE, China has a crusade against “busywork” to rescue it.

Here is another interesting article on China’s high speed rail. It includes the following obvious statement about the befits of rail:

Anecdotally (which is to say, going by videos that various content creators have posted on social media), people simply love traveling by high-speed rail. Unlike driving, which requires some degree of skill, attention, and effort, the (much faster) trains allow people to travel in complete relaxation. And, unlike airplanes, which require you to go through airports and then sit squeezed into a tiny seat with no space to move, the trains are incredibly easy to board and comfortable once you’re in your seat. 

what this ignores is the huge amount of wasted time taken by flying over the same distance. You wait to check-in, drop-off luggage, through security, at the boarding gate, waiting to board and of course the same in reverse. The problem with flights is not just that airports tend to be outside the city, but even when you go to board, there is one small entrance through which everyone funnels.

Maybe you are lucky to do some work prior to boarding at the gate? Maybe your airline has big enough seats to do some real work, rather than just scrolling on your phone. On a high speed train there are usually doors at either end of every carriage. The seats can be bigger and often have fixed tables, because, well trains can be bigger. The one in the above video is only 4x cars, which is typically small.

If your high speed rail train takes 2-hours to travel 250+ miles, you can probably bet on being able to work, be productive or just sleep for 1-hour, 45-mins of that. Compared to a flight, where with take-off and landing, you’d be lucky to get 20-mins.

Ahh well, dream-on.

Leave a Reply